The Vedânta-Sûtras, Part II, with the Commentary by Sankarâkârya — SBE Vol. 38

The phrase, ' as in the case of the horse,' supplies an illustration on the ground of suitability. As the horse, owing to its specific suitability, is not employed for dragging ploughs but is harnessed to chariots ; so the works enjoined on the aj'ramas are not required by knowledge for bringing about its results, but with a view to its own origination.

27. But all the same he (who is desirous of knowledge) must be possessed of calmness, subjection of the senses, &c., since those (states) are enjoined as auxiliaries to that (viz. knowledge), and must (on that account) necessarily be accomplished.

X 2

p. 108

Perhaps somebody might think that we have no right to look upon sacrifices and the Hke as means of knowledge because there is no injunction to that effect. For a passage like ' By sacrifice they seek to know ' is of the nature of an anuvada, and therefore does not aim at enjoining sacrifices but rather at glorifying knowledge, ' so glorious is knowledge that they seek to obtain it through sacrifices and the like.'

But even should this be so the seeker for knowledge must possess calmness of mind, must subdue his senses and so on ; for all this is enjoined as a means of knowledge in the following scriptural passage, 'Therefore he who knows this, having become calm, subdued, satisfied, patient, and collected, sees self in Self (Brz. Up. IV, 4, 23). And what is enjoined must necessarily be carried out. — But in the above passage also we observe only a statement as to something actually going on — ' Having become calm, &c., he sees,' not an injunction ! — Not so, we reply. The introductory word ' therefore ' which expresses praise of the subject under discussion makes us understand that the passage has an injunctive character^.

Moreover the text of the Madhyandinas directly reads 'let him see' (not 'he sees'). Hence calmness of mind and so on are required even if sacrifices, &c., should not be required. — Sacrifices and so on, however, are required likewise, because (as said in Sutra 26) scripture teaches them. — But it has been said that in the passage, ' Him they seek to know by sacrifices,' no injunction is observed ! — True ; but nevertheless we must assume the passage to be an injunction, because the connexion of the search for knowledge with sacrifices and so on is something new ; i.e. is not established by another text, and therefore the

^ For if there were no injunction, the praise would be without meaning. The ' therefore ' connects the passage with the preceding clause, ' he is not sullied by any evil deed.' The sense then is, ' Because he who knows the Self as described before is not sullied by any evil deed, therefore let him, after having become calm, &C.J see the Self, and so on.'

Ill ADHYAYA, 4 PADA, 2S. 3O9

passage under discussion cannot be an anuvada referring to it. The case is analogous to that of passages such as ' therefore Pushan ^ receives a well-crushed share of food, for he is toothless.' There also no injunction is directlystated ; but as the matter of the passage is new we assume an injunction and understand that the grains for Pushan are to be crushed at all vikr/tis of the darj-apur/zamasa ; as was explained in the Purva Mimdwsa.