The Enneads — trans. Stephen MacKenna

etimes, however, like Plato, Plotinus makes Matter “ The Other-than-Being ” : cf. I. 8, 3, and I. 8, 5, pages 94, 97 of this volume.

III. 6, 7. “ Matter is without body ; body is of earlier date (less distant from the Divine) and merely includes Matter . . . neither is Matter a spirit or a mind, it is not life, it is not a Reason-Form or Idea, it is not a limit ; it might be more nearly described as a boundlessness ; it is not a power or potentiality ; it produces nothing and since it is none of the things of this sphere it cannot come under the name of an Existent ; it is, rather, Not-Being ; and it is not even this in the sense in which Motion and Rest may be called Not-Being ; it is merely a phantasm or shadow of space, an aspiration towards existence ; it is present where no one sees ; it ever eludes the eye that searches for it ... it comprises all the contraries, the little and the great, the more and the less ... it is a ghostly thing incapable alike of staying or going since it has drawn no force from the Divine : and, so, all its pretence of existence is a lie.”

From Plotinus’ doctrine it would follow that wherever there is Non-Being or defect of Being, there must be some presence of Matter ; that would seem to be the case even in the Soul, even in the Divine Mind ; but Plotinus will not allow Matter There (?).

X

Soul and Body

IV. 3, 9. The entry of a Soul into a body may take place in one of two ways. In one case it has already been in an earthly body and changes for another, or having been in a body of fire or air (an ” astral ” body) it enters for the first time into an earthly body. ... In another case it has been previously outside of any body, but chooses one now and so enters for the first time into relation with the material universe. At present we are to deal only with this second case. . . . We begin with the Soul-of-the-All. . . . We must use such phrases as ” entry of the Soul ”

SOUL AND BODY

p. 149

and “ ensouling the world,” though there never was a time when this All was without Soul, never a time when the frame of the universe held together in the absence of Soul, never a time when Matter was crude and unordered (n). We separate them. Soul and Body, Form and Matter, only to be enabled to discuss them clearly ; there is no combination which the reasoning faculties may not resolve into its elements.

If Body, the body-kind, had not existed the Soul could never have gone forth from itself, for there exists no other place to which its nature would allow it to resort.

; there is no combination which the reasoning faculties may not resolve into its elements.

If Body, the body-kind, had not existed the Soul could never have gone forth from itself, for there exists no other place to which its nature would allow it to resort. If it is to go forth from itself, it must provide a suitable place ; it must shape itself a body.

Now the Soul (as a Divine Hypostasis) is motionless, with an immobility rooted in immobility’s self (the immobility which is one of the Categories of the world of Authentic-Existence) but it may be thought of as a powerful light shining forth afar ; at the uttermost reach of its fires there must be darkness (n) : once this darkness exists the Soul must see it, and, by seeing it, give it form, for the Law could not allow anything that is near to Soul to be without some share in Divine Idea. . . .

The Kosmos, the ordered and patterned system thus produced, becomes like a stately and varied mansion not disov/ned by its architect though not identical with him ; it is judged worthy in every inch of all its builder’s care in adding beauty to its being, as far as existence is possible to Matter and without prejudice to the Maker who presides over it from the eternal seat Above (n).

Thus is the All ensouled, with a spirit not its own but communicated to it : governed by Soul, not governing it ; not so much possessing as possessed by Soul. For the Universe lies within this maintaining Spirit and no recess of it is wholly void of Soul (n) : it may be compared to a net that takes all its life from being wet in the waters and still is never able to move of its own motion there, but as the sea tosses it the net is spread out, exactly to the full of its reach, no mesh of it able to push beyond its own set place.

The Soul, outside all the limits of space and quantity, is able to embrace within its unvarying force the entire body of the All, and is ever at the furthest and the nearest point which the All includes (n). The Universe spreads as broad and wide as the presence of the Soul, and it stretches as far as the outflow of life from the Soul proceeds.

Notes

” Never a time.” Plotinus makes the world eternal on the ground that there could never be a time at which the Eternal Principles were unproductive.

” Darkness ” : — Cf. I. 8, 4, and I. 8, 5, pages 96-7 of this volume.

PLOTINUS

p. 150

“ Presides over it ” : — This refers to the prior Soul. In other places Plotinus utterly denies a fall of the Soul : —

II. 9, 4.

ch the Eternal Principles were unproductive.

” Darkness ” : — Cf. I. 8, 4, and I. 8, 5, pages 96-7 of this volume.

PLOTINUS

p. 150

“ Presides over it ” : — This refers to the prior Soul. In other places Plotinus utterly denies a fall of the Soul : —

II. 9, 4. “ Is it to be thought that creation comes about because the Soul has lost its wings ? Such a catastrophe cannot be conceived of the Divine All-Soul. We hear of its Fall : but, why and how, and when ? If it fell from all eternity, then it is eternally a fallen thing ; if we fix a time, why not earlier or later ? We hold that the Kosmos was produced by no such fall : the creation, rather, came about by the Soul’s not falling. If the Soul fell that could be only by its forgetting the things of the Supreme ; but if it forget that Sphere, how could it create this ? From what model does it work but from what it sees There ? If then it creates from the vision of the Divine Realities, it can never have fallen.”

“ Adding Beauty ” ; — “ All things that exist in the Universe have Soul and vital force and are images of the eternal life in the Divine and Intellectual Kosmos. The Universe is consummate in beauty and only the witless could revile it ; —

II. 9, 4. “ Nor can we admit that this universe is ill-constructed because of the many flaws that may be found in it : such a complaint would rank it high indeed — as if it were the Intellectual Universe itself and not merely an image of that Divine Sphere.”

The very evil in the universe contributes towards the good ; the Providence of God nowhere shines more brightly than in His power to turn evil to His purposes ; —

III. 2, 5. ” Vice itself is not without its usefulness to the All ; it exhibits the beauty and the rightness of virtue ; it calls up the intelligence to oppose the evil course ; it manifests the value and grace there is in goodness by displaying the cost of sin. No doubt evil has not essentially anything to do with these purposes, but once it is there it serves in working out great ends ; and only a mighty power could thus turn the ignoble to noble uses and employ to the purposes of form what has risen in formless lawlessness.”

” The Furthest and Nearest Point ” : — For the world is a living-being penetrated with life, and all its members are working together towards one end : —

IV. 4, 32 : ” We must look upon this Universe with all the lives within it as one living-being having for all its parts one soul which reaches to every member, to every object existing in the sense-known scheme. . . .