Goethe sets colour on the side of shadow, a degree of darkness, and approves Kircher's "lumen opacatum". "As it is allied to shadow, so it combines readily" with it. Papus's Traité élémentaire, on this shelf, starts its whole method from the same observation (light, shadow and the penumbra between them) and then generalises the penumbra into the neutral third of every pair: father, mother and child; acid, base and their neutral. The difference is what each does next. Goethe stays with the phenomenon and turns it into an instrument: a coloured shadow can serve as a "chromatoscope of the illumined surface". Papus observes his penumbra once and makes it a key. Kircher links the two: Goethe cites him here, and Papus lists his books in his bibliography.
contrasts with Traité élémentaire de science occulte — Papus (Gérard Encausse) (1888)