Two books on this shelf, both in editions of 1888, each name one struggle as the key to history. The Manifesto makes it the struggle of classes. Papus's Traité élémentaire makes it the struggle of authority against power, and draws the opposite conclusion about secrecy: authority, persecuted by despots, wraps its teaching in mystery, and initiation is how truth survives. The Manifesto closes by refusing exactly that: "The Communists disdain to conceal their views and aims." It opened the same way, setting a published manifesto against the tale of a spectre. Read side by side, they give two answers to whether a doctrine that expects to prevail should be taught in the open.
contrasts with Traité élémentaire de science occulte — Papus (Gérard Encausse) (1888)